Missing discourse about climate change in Indian Parliament
Seema Mundoli and Harini Nagendra, faculty at Azim Premji University, Bengaluru, highlight how parliamentary oversight in a well-functioning democracy can play an important role in climate change policy, ensuring that climate concerns are represented in national agendas.
Only 0.3% of the questions asked in Parliament are on climate change, and they are not asked by the states most vulnerable to climate change. The text of the questions also misses raising concerns of equity and justice, for the most part. Overall, very little is being done to use Parliament to drive climate action. This is based on a dataset that looks at a 20-year period from 1999 to 2019.
Parliamentary questions (PQs) are a crucial oversight tool available to parliamentarians in all democracies. In a well-functioning democracy, parliamentary oversight can play an important role in climate change policy, ensuring that climate concerns are represented in national agendas. India is the largest democracy in the world and one of the countries most vulnerable to climate change. Over a 20 year period, from 1999 to 2019, we examine whether parliamentarians used PQs to address climate change issues in India. We asked four questions:
a) How often are PQs raised about climate change?
b) Are vulnerable constituency interests being represented in the Parliament?
c) What kinds of questions do parliamentarians ask?
d) Where do parliamentarians get their information on climate change from?
895 unique PQs related to climate change were raised by 1019 Ministers, forming only a fraction (∼0.3%) of the total PQs asked in parliament during this period, however the number of PQs related to climate change increased over time.
PQs were not raised by the states most vulnerable to climate change, nor did they represent the concerns of socially vulnerable groups. The PQs were mostly concerned about the impacts (27.6%) and mitigation (23.4%) of climate change.
Impacts on agriculture (38.3%), coastal changes (28.6%), and health (13.4%) were of main interest, along with mitigation issues related to energy (43.6%), agriculture (21.8%), and aviation (9.1%).
Despite the significant and growing vulnerability of India to climate change, PQs related to climate change were largely missing. Although they have increased over time, we still find there is substantial room for growth, especially in critical areas of climate justice and adaptation relevant to the Indian context. Raising the level of parliamentary debate on climate change is critical and needs to be foregrounded.
Researchers: Seema Mundoli, Zubin Jacob, Ranjini Murali and Harini Nagendra
Know more about our research centres here.
Centre for Climate Change and Sustainability
Strengthening India's response to the climate crisis